The Benefits and Efficacy of Glucosamine for Dogs

1. Introduction

Glucosamine is a compound that is gaining attention due to its benefits. It has become popular due to the increasing use of glucosamine in supplements and functional foods to support the health and wellness of dogs. One of the primary uses of the glucosamine compound is in supporting joint health and agility in dogs. Glucosamine is a favored ingredient in popular mobility supplements due to its many benefits. These supplements are often taken as a way to stave off or reduce joint-related issues in dogs such as arthritis, dysplasia, or osteoarthritis. Natural glucosamine can therefore be found in the shells of shellfish and the bones and cartilage of cows. In order to have this compound in a more accessible form, methods have been developed to extract and concentrate glucosamine. This concentrated glucosamine is then sold in formats such as supplements, soft chews, or as a powder to mix into a dog's food. In both humans and dogs, the popularity of glucosamine is increasing. Dog owners who want the best quality of life for their pets are looking for ways to help ensure a long and active lifestyle for their pets. Glucosamine, a dietary supplement used by humans to support joint health and mobility, is now being used by many dog owners to support their pets' joint health as well. The supplement supports the health of the synovial fluid, which allows joints to move painlessly, by covering the joint cartilage and reducing the degradation of joint tissues. Glucosamine consumption also increases liver health by preventing free radicals from crossing the liver. Over the last few decades, many clinical and laboratory experiments in humans and animals have confirmed the efficacy of glucosamine in promoting cartilage and joint development, making it the most common component in arthritis treatment.

1.1. What is Glucosamine?

Glucosamine is an amino sugar. The "building blocks" of proteins, amino sugars, and glucose connect in the body to create glucosamine. An amino sugar is a molecule created when an amino group replaces the end hydrogen of a sugar molecule. The body's small intestine absorbs glucosamine. To build and repair healthy cartilage, the body also uses it as raw material, especially supportive cartilage such as spinal discs. Glucosamine is used by the body in various forms. Glucosamine sulfate is the most popular commercially. Another kind, known as glucosamine hydrochloride, is less expensive, but scientists question its effectiveness. Despite this, numerous glucosamine-chondroitin mixtures include the hydrochloride variety. N-acetyl glucosamine may also be seen on some items. When compared to the commercially available forms, scientists believe it is not as effective. With its anti-inflammatory properties, glucosamine helps decrease joint discomfort and irritation. Many scientific studies have shown that glucosamine can help animals with joint problems. The well-being of the musculoskeletal system of dogs is often aided by a supplement of glucosamine. Nutraceuticals are substances like glucosamine that are used to promote the health of an animal and are often used in mixes. Glucosamine, though, is a pharmaceutical that is more successful than other drugs when delivered as a stand-alone drug. It's essential to know the basic differences between these nutrients when evaluating supplements with glucosamine. The most popular joint-related nutrients for dogs are glucosamine alone, chondroitin sulfate, and fish oils like omega-3 fatty acids.

1.2. Sources of Glucosamine

Glucosamine is used in one of the most often found sources in supplements, which is considered to be the most effective for commercial use, from their shells. Furthermore, glucosamine from synthetic origins is safe and is said to be bioequivalent to natural glucosamine, and is often vegan. The commercial sources of glucosamine from shellfish are predominantly from shrimp, followed by crabs, and are extracted mainly from the shells as opposed to prawn tails. The processes by which glucosamine can be extracted naturally are either by digestion, filtration, and centrifugation, or by enzymatic extraction, or by a combination of two or more of these methods followed by crystallization. Of interest, glucosamine can also be derived from by-products from the manufacture of chicken stock by an acid hydrochloric extraction method. Furthermore, vegetarian glucosamine options are also available. The options to consider using include NAG, glucosamine sulfate, and glucosamine HCl.

To administer glucosamine, there are several options available such as capsules, powder, and consumable treats. With the variety of glucosamine supplements available, a parameter to consider is the source of glucosamine. The origin of the glucosamine can also impact its potency and hence efficacy as an OA treatment. It was identified that regardless of their source, the quality of a glucosamine supplement could vary significantly between brands. The efficacy of glucosamine is a good point of discussion, as there is evidence to support its effectiveness, but there are also many studies that are inconclusive. Thus, the quality of the ingredients used is also important for encouraging other staff members to advise their customers effectively. In conclusion, the key considerations are whether this treatment will provide a safe, efficacious option, and the need to consider the source and potency of the treatment being used to ensure it is effective.

2. The Role of Glucosamine in Joint Health

A dog’s skeletal structure relies entirely on the proper function of its joints. Several complex processes contribute to this functionality, including the repair and regeneration of cartilage. Without this support, joint-related issues such as arthritis may arise, ultimately leading to adverse health effects in dogs. One compound that has been gaining an extensive amount of attention in the past decade is glucosamine. Present in both humans and animals, glucosamine is believed to act as a chondroprotective agent, responsible for reducing the occurrence of osteoarthritis in dogs and promoting overall joint health. It does so via three key functions in the body.

The most common reason why pet owners introduce glucosamine into their dog’s diet is to maintain or improve synovial fluid levels. Also known as joint fluid, the compound functions as a lubricant, helping human and dog joints work easier and more pain-free. Because of the globe’s love for our furry friends, many studies are done on glucosamine for humans, and there is a plethora of evidence supporting the positive impact of the compound on joint stiffness and swelling. Glucosamine’s second function is to produce specific cells in the body and cartilage known as proteoglycans, which are necessary for the cartilage to maintain and repair itself. Collagen, the most prominent structural protein present in cartilage, is also accelerated by the helpful properties of glucosamine to function as a shock absorber. Ultimately, glucosamine is an effective cartilage repair treatment.

2.1. Structure and Function of Joints

Part of being a responsible dog owner is keeping an eye on your dog's health. From the very onset, you should be watching for signs of joint issues. It is a well-known fact that canine joints are surrounded by generally rigid protective structures, consisting of ligaments, joint capsule, tendons, and in some instances, bone. These bony affixations are covered with articular cartilage, which reduces friction during joint movement. Some joints contain disks or menisci, which add to this congruity of movement. Inside these capsules, the bones of a joint are joined by highly innervated and vascularized structures as well as synovium, which generates synovial fluid. This fluid performs a number of life-supporting functions for the joint, such as nourishment of the avascular articular cartilage, shock absorption, lubrication of articular surfaces, temperature regulation, and metabolic waste removal. It is essentially the 'life-blood' of the joint. The overall mechanical integrity of articular dyads or triads within a joint is crucial because any impairment of one component can and will impact upon and impair the function of the others to differing degrees.

The joint capsule, ligaments, and tendons are essentially acting as check reins, constricting the movement of the more spheroidal structures and preventing luxation or overextension. Therefore, a joint or segments of a joint are largely stabilized by the strength and integrity of these muscles and are further supported by the presence of a meniscal structure. However, the function of these muscles and no more than 20–25% of a dog’s body weight can do so much. Reducing the surface area of and adding extra weight to a dog’s foot will make a joint more unstable. Impaired articular proprioception can then cause the muscles to be hypotonic or hypertonic, making the joint unstable.

2.2. How Glucosamine Supports Joint Health

Glucosamine is highly beneficial for dogs, and part of the reason for this is its mechanism of action. It is believed that glucosamine helps dogs by being incorporated into the glycosaminoglycans that are necessary for the formation and maintenance of healthy cartilage. Because glucosamine may be involved in the synthesis of necessary cartilage components, a beneficial effect of glucosamine supplementation is through slow action to promote general well-being and good everyday health in older dogs and dogs predisposed to degenerative joint diseases and osteoarthritis. One way glucosamine works is by decreasing cartilage destruction, reducing inflammation and pain. Secondly, glucosamine increases the production of the synovial fluid that decreases inflammation. The substance has also shown to restore joint health and have anti-inflammatory characteristics.

The mechanism of glucosamine with glycosaminoglycans tends to slow down the progression of osteoarthritis in dogs. Glucosamine has been shown to regenerate tissue, and it can prevent further wear and tear. As a result, it encourages collagen formation, which serves as a form of a cushion for the terminally worn arthritic bone ends. The purpose of joint supplements is to reduce and ultimately eliminate pain. Adequate amounts of glycosaminoglycans assist the cartilage in maintaining an optimal amount of water, which makes the cartilage elastic and able to withstand pressure. Osteoarthritis can be decelerated by enhancing the production of glycosaminoglycans and chondroitin sulfate. Different supplements provide different outcomes, but by supplementing with glucosamine directly, pet owners are sure to see a difference. In contrast, by being absorbed in the small intestines and entering the bloodstream, glucosamine HCL is used by the whole body, traveling to joints and ligaments to provide pain relief and encourage repair. Synergistically combining several supplements aimed at better bone and joint strength and repair is backbone therapy.

3. Scientific Evidence and Studies

In recent years, many investigations have dealt with the potential benefits of glucosamine for canine joint health. One of the available brands of glucosamine for dogs involves chondroitin and omega-3, and it is able to reduce pain just in the first week of therapy and to improve locomotion in four weeks of treatment. It is pointed out that a compound like Piascledine that includes all three of these molecules packaged in a single chewable tablet may have obvious major benefits of convenience in terms of possible welfare, particularly in geriatric patients or animals with mobility problems who are able to keep the Piascledine directly administered with food. In a multicentered study conducted in the United States, significantly different results were observed. A total of 41 veterinary clinics, including 250 dogs with signs of mild-to-moderate OA in one or more joints, were treated with glucosamine and the results showed a significant improvement in lameness at every 30, 60, 90, and 120 days of treatment. The results of these two studies would confirm the usefulness of glucosamine against pain mainly in the first period of use, and in the improvement of movement that will be appreciable in the subsequent weeks of therapy. However, more studies are necessary to offer veterinary professionals and pet owners a solid base of clinical evidence useful for the best treatment choices to alleviate OA in pets.

3.1. Key Studies on Glucosamine for Dogs

The objective of the study startup was to assess the improvement in perceived and observed quality of life and comfort associated with the use of a daily regimen of chewable glucosamine and chondroitin supplements to support joint health and mobility. In clinical settings, joints were scored and gait was analyzed at startup, and at 30, 60, and 90 days of the study. The pet owner completed a perceived quality of life and comfort survey which assessed six categories: lameness, ease in rising, ease in lying down, willingness to run and play, and willingness to ascend and descend stairs. The study enrolled 40 client-owned dogs with some degree of musculoskeletal discomfort primarily associated with hip dysplasia and osteoarthritis. This study revealed a statistically significant improvement in joint health, range of motion, observed gait, and quality of life in dogs receiving glucosamine supplements compared with dogs in the placebo control group. Owners of study patients indicated that there were fewer clinical signs of musculoskeletal discomfort in the group receiving glucosamine and chondroitin supplements.

Building on this initial and very promising startup study, a multi-million dollar grant was awarded to Michigan State University College of Veterinary Medicine, with Elena and Dan visiting their campus to be study coordinators for a 5-year extensive study. No study has been conceived with such extensive double-blind clinical components and with veterinarians conducting all exams to date. Glucosamine for dogs was one of the few over-the-counter products that were noted to be effective. The present study was a controlled, 13-center field investigation implemented as a double-masked, four-parallel design. Briefly, 95 dogs completed the 24-week study. There were significant improvements in veterinary assessments of discomfort, owner assessments of physical function, and quality of life. The glucosamine group showed a statistically significant reduction in weakness, while the control group experienced a five-fold decrease in willingness to do stairs. No significant difference was seen between the two groups in any serious side effects. Overall, this study adds significant weight to recommendations that the use of chewable glucosamine for dogs may have a role in chronic joint disease.

3.2. Effectiveness and Safety

In dogs with OA, glucosamine in supplements has been proven to be effective in reducing pain and improving the dog's mobility, as well as reducing the owner-perceived pain, in the mild and moderate stages of OA. Currently, the safety of oral glucosamine administration for dogs is very high. The study of the state of the art on the topic found that side effects related to glucosamine treatment are very odd or uncommon responses to treatment. The main mechanism of action of glucosamine is related to the reduction of the inflammatory response. Specifically, this drug modulates the TLR4/MyD88/NF-κB pathway, which inhibits the release of inflammatory cytokines. MyD88 is a major adaptor molecule that plays a crucial role in the TLRs/IL-1R signaling pathway. This pathway leads to the activation of NF-κB genes, which encode many proinflammatory cytokines, including TNF, IL-6, IL-1β, and IL-18. These are believed to play key roles in the pathological progression and pain associated with OA.

However, although rare, gastrointestinal upset, an elevation in liver-related enzyme activity, changes in pancreatic exocrine secretion, weight gain, and changes in insulin response to food have also been reported, with higher doses being related to a proportionally greater risk of side effects. It may not be safe to administer glucosamine to all dogs. Its effect is more pronounced in some dogs and less pronounced in others; a veterinarian can help recommend suitable doses for individual cases. It is important to have a proper assessment of a dog's running, walking, and playing activities from time to time to judge whether this supplement is still necessary or whether adjustment is needed. In dogs with severe OA, there are cases in which the surgical corrections of OA using total hip replacement or tibial plateau leveling osteotomy repair the CCL is more effective than glucosamine. Dog owners should refer to their veterinarians if their dog does not show any improvement or appears to be getting worse after receiving glucosamine for two months. Since the effectiveness of supplements may be affected by other factors, such as appropriate feed types and amounts, it is important that dog owners communicate effectively with their veterinarians about the proper assessment of the drugs provided.

4. Choosing the Right Glucosamine Supplement

Choose the Right Glucosamine Supplement for Your Dog When it comes time for you to choose a supplement, know there are many formulations on the market and you should understand them. There are two primary types of glucosamine: glucosamine sulfate and glucosamine hydrochloride. Some pet parents believe that glucosamine sulfate is a superior source of glucosamine even though many studies have shown that there is no real difference in benefits between the two types. It’s just that there have been more studies on glucosamine sulfate than on hydrochloride. There are also other ingredients typically used in dog supplements that have been shown to enhance the effects of glucosamine, such as chondroitin and methylsulfonylmethane. You might check to see if the product you’re considering contains any of these. Some brands are just better than others. Look for products that have been tested and bear the seal. You can also reach out to customer service and ask if they comply with inspection standards and request a Certificate of Analysis. A COA provides testing data conducted by an independent laboratory and will confirm the potency and purity of the ingredients in the supplement. Also, ask if the company is a Good Manufacturing Practices facility. They should also have a customer service number for you to call with any questions. Labels are hard to interpret. A “guaranteed levels per two chews” claim does not mean that there are that many glucosamine and MSM in two chews. Label guarantees don’t have to equal label values. No information demonstrates a direct relationship between label guarantees and the amount of nutrients in the product. The company performs quality testing. There should also be a code printed on the label that shows the product was approved. If when you call the customer service number to ask for a COA the customer service representative has no explanation nor solution to what the code means, steer clear. Some buyers may be concerned about high-moisture pet foods and treats when dealing with oral supplements in reaction to unnecessary dietary administration. To make things easier, purchase prepackaged oral supplements with a COA so both you and your doctor know what your pet is taking. Dosage guidelines are the same for both humans and dogs. They can be found in each bottle. In addition, the “inactive ingredients” can include allergens such as sweeteners and artificial flavors. Whether human or pet oriented, every product is different. Make sure that no inactive or other ingredients in the product can pose a problem for the pet. The greatest variety is available in capsule form. For professional treatment, however, opt for a liquid or treat. Regular medications will initiate a quicker recovery and in this case, capsules are easier to combine with other therapies.

4.1. Different Forms of Glucosamine

Glucosamine and chondroitin are often co-administered as dietary supplements for humans, horses, and dogs. Because sulfated glycosaminoglycans can be derived from glucosamine, these two compounds share a biochemical pathway and are thought to have synergistic effects. We can only assume that these synergistic effects are also valid for dogs. This subsection focuses purely on glucosamine, while the combination of glucosamine and chondroitin will be covered later. While various forms of glucosamine are available in dietary supplements for humans and dogs, the most common in dietary supplements (and the focus of this subsection) are glucosamine sulfate, glucosamine hydrochloride, and N-acetyl glucosamine. A common claim is that glucosamine hydrochloride is more concentrated than the "sulfate" form, but this is a misnomer based on the different amounts of elemental sulfur or sulfates present when changing from glucosamine hydrochloride to glucosamine sulfate and cannot be used as an argument for a higher glucosamine concentration in dietary supplements.

When ingested, because of the acidic environment of the stomach or during the manufacturing process and dosage form, glucosamine sulfate is usually found in its potassium or sodium salts. Hence, glucosamine sulfate is often marketed under various names such as glucosamine sulfate KCl or glucosamine sulfate sodium. Absorption differences might exist depending on the form of glucosamine used in dietary supplements. The different physical forms of glucosamine may influence bioavailability and are thought to modulate its pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics. To date, only one study in healthy human volunteers has investigated the pharmacokinetics of glucosamine hydrochloride and the potassium salt of glucosamine sulfate, showing that both dietary supplements were bioequivalent for glucosamine bioavailability after a single oral administration. However, worsening osteoarthritis with increasing age, erosive osteoarthritis, or an abnormal individual response to glucosamine therapy may indicate a defective glucosamine bioavailability in certain populations.

4.2. Dosage and Administration

The appropriate dosage for glucosamine used in dogs will depend on the animal’s size and individual health status. For example, a chewable containing 125-250 mg of glucosamine per tablet is suitable for small dogs, while larger breeds require approximately 500-750 mg of the supplement. However, the best way for pet owners to gauge dosage is to rely on the advice of a veterinarian who knows the dog’s personal needs and history. The supplement can be given in tablet form, in liquid form, or in a powder that can be added to a dog’s food. The most effective supplements are those that have a palatable flavor and are easy for a dog to digest. Giving the supplement every day at the same time, even when there are no apparent symptoms, is crucial for long-term results. Usually, if no improvement is seen within 6-8 weeks, the dosage is either increased or the dog is switched to a different joint supplement.

The dosage can also be slowly increased over time as a dog ages and joint issues become more serious. Any improvements inconsistent with the progression of the condition may signal that the dosage requires alteration. Owners should carefully monitor dogs while administering these treatments for any signs of negative reactions or refusal to eat or drink or abide by the treatment guideline.

5. Conclusion

It is clear that contemporary literature supports the benefits of glucosamine in dogs in relation to joint health and joint mobility as a nutritional supplement, although this is very much informed by the specific studies that have been conducted regarding this supplement and species. Significantly, the use of scientific evidence and directed research has informed industry and the market in supplementation practices. As far as glucosamine supplementation is concerned, research has facilitated the regulation of glucosamine products to provide quality products that assure efficacy for animals. Research continues, with exploration around the basic biological function of glucosamine in metabolism and therefore if supplement benefit is possible.

One of the important factors to consider is that glucosamine is relatively safe, with good palatability, and can be included in the diet to provide health support. There is some invalidation in the canine setting for peripheral joint abnormalities such as hip dysplasia and/or elbow dysplasia being supported with nutritional supplementation. It is clear that, for all the associated evidence in the literature, there is certainly no harm in using glucosamine supplementation as a preventative tool in slowing the onset of joint deterioration. There are important considerations in the quality of the product, the dose required to inform efficacy, and consideration of the time required to show an effect and therefore the role that it has within an individual animal’s health status and treatment. Further research is required to validate current practice and product claims and identify new applications and benefits of the compound in clinical practice.

5.1. Summary of Benefits

Glucosamine prevents joint deterioration. It has been suggested that joint fluid and tissues contain higher levels of glucosamine after it is administered. This suggests that the body uses the sugar alongside other nutrients for managing inflammation, reducing the formation of new bony growths around the joints, and maintaining optimal health within the joints that have already formed. Additionally, it has been suggested that glucosamine helps to prevent the loss of minerals within cartilage so that joint lubrication and cushioning continue. As such, glucosamine has been found to decrease the discomfort caused by osteoarthritis, reduce the length of time it takes for joint swelling to improve after injury, and increase weight-bearing ability and thus mobility within dogs.

Literally thousands of dog owners whose arthritic four-legged companions had much improvement after starting glucosamine. A study to objectively evaluate glucosamine's effect on canine mobility demonstrated improvement of the hips and knees for dogs whose owners were skeptical that the sugar produced any health benefits. The evaluators used various tools to provide them with unbiased readings. Whether statistical measurements or the success of other dog owners are any proof doesn't matter; however, the bottom line is that there is an increasing amount of scientific and anecdotal evidence as to why glucosamine is so popular. That said, never start additional supplements without first advising a veterinarian of your intentions.

5.2. Future Research Directions

The field of glucosamine and chondroitin has progressed substantially since getting its start at least 15 years ago; however, we cannot claim to have all the answers. Research is still needed to discover the optimum supplement dosage for dogs. More is needed that would look specifically at longer-term glucosamine administration to healthy dogs and the exact levels needed to reach maximal efficacy, i.e., the level of dosing that provides no additional benefit. Additionally, the potential long-term effects of extended glucosamine administration require exploration. Furthermore, the effects of glucosamine have not been tested in specific breeds or in some populations of dogs, i.e., other than growing dogs or older animals with one or another joint dysfunction. The question of glucosamine’s effectiveness in severe cases of canine hip dysplasia needs to be addressed with additional clinical trials and ultimately a continued depth of ongoing basic research that may shed light on the mechanism that drives cartilage degradation and joint inflammation.

The interaction of glucosamine and other joint supplements with NSAIDs, COX-2 inhibitors, and other drugs as well as diet is also of potential interest. Various other unanswered questions, from the best way to administer glucosamine and chondroitin to the necessity for daily long-term administration of the supplements, demand exploration. The complementary approach of several classes of drugs in the treatment of osteoarthritis, as well as surgery and exercise or physical therapy, will likely continue to consume large portions of research. Careful phase I pharmacokinetics studies and clinical phase II studies could help to eliminate inactive and untoward combinations of drugs or other supplements, which may minimize arthrocenteses and hence may increase efficiency in the area of clinical research. It is unlikely that any one company would be able to afford so much time, money, or effort in this area, and thus our view is that a cooperative effort between veterinarians, supplement manufacturers, and other lucrative manufacturers could vastly progress this field.

References:

Eckert, T., Jährling-Butkus, M., Louton, H., Burg-Roderfeld, M., Zhang, N., Zhang, R., Hesse, K., Petridis, A.K., Kožár, T., Steinmeyer, J. and Schauer, R., 2021. Biophysical, Biochemical and Biomedical Evaluation of Collagen Hydrolysate in Comparison to Sulfated Glucosamine from Marine Organisms and Lipids of Fish Oil Origin Used as Chondroprotective Food Supplements. preprints.org

Gencoglu, H., Orhan, C., Sahin, E., & Sahin, K., 2020. Undenatured type II collagen (UC-II) in joint health and disease: a review on the current knowledge of companion animals. Animals. mdpi.com

Eckert, T., Jährling-Butkus, M., Louton, H., Burg-Roderfeld, M., Zhang, R., Zhang, N., Hesse, K., Petridis, A.K., Kožár, T., Steinmeyer, J. and Schauer, R., 2021. Efficacy of chondroprotective food supplements based on collagen hydrolysate and compounds isolated from marine organisms. Marine drugs, 19(10), p.542. mdpi.com

Abood, S.K. and Wara, A.M., 2020. Combining Nutrition and Physical Rehabilitation to Improve Health Outcomes for Dogs and Cats. Advances in Small Animal Care, 1, pp.239-264. advancesinsmallanimalcare.com

Langley‐Hobbs, S., 2023. Update on diagnosing and managing osteoarthritis in cats. In Practice. [HTML]

Sawant, K., 2024. Optimizing Animal Health and Performance through Nutritional Strategies: Insights for Veterinary Practice. Revista Electronica de Veterinaria. veterinaria.org

Levine, D., Pancotto, T.E., Martins, Â.P., Vrbanac, Z., Lewis, M.J., Amaral Marrero, N.P., Thomovsky, S.A., Linder, J.E., Bowditch, J., Lind, M. and Kazmierczak, K.A., 2023. frontiers Frontiers in Veterinary Science ORIGINAL RESEARCH published: 04 April 2022. Sports medicine and physical rehabilitation, volume II, p.30. [HTML]

Koh, R., Montalbano, C., Gamble, L.J., Walden, K., Rouse, J., Liu, C.C., Wakshlag, L.G. and Wakshlag, J.J., 2020. Internet survey of feeding, dietary supplement, and rehabilitative medical management use in flyball dogs. The Canadian Veterinary Journal, 61(4), p.375. nih.gov