Strategies for Managing Excessive Barking in Dogs

1. Introduction

Excessive barking is a commonly reported problem behavior in pet dogs. From the dog owners' perspective, excessive barking may decrease the quality of life and potentially impact the dog's future in the home. Unfortunately, barking is complex and the response of both the owner and the dog to barking can be equally challenging. Subject matter experts explored various options to address excessive barking in dogs . Professional behavior modification: This involves working with an animal behavior specialist to identify the causes of excessive barking and implementing strategies to reduce or eliminate it. This may include techniques such as positive reinforcement to encourage desired behaviors , Medication use: In some cases, medication may be prescribed to help calm a dog that is barking excessively, especially if the barking is related to anxiety or stress , Procedural changes: This could refer to changes in the dog’s daily routine or environment to reduce the stimuli that trigger the barking. For example, avoiding leaving the dog alone for long periods of time or providing more mental and physical stimulation , Humane training: This involves educating dog owners on how to manage and respond to barking appropriately. Sometimes, owners may unintentionally reinforce barking by giving the dog attention when it barks , Management techniques: This may include measures such as using anti-bark collars or installing physical barriers to prevent the dog from seeing what might trigger its barking , Reducing territoriality and social facilitation: Excessive barking can sometimes be related to territoriality, where a dog barks to protect its territory, or social facilitation, where a dog barks in response to the barking of other dogs. Reducing these behaviors may involve limiting the dog's exposure to situations where it feels territorial or influenced by other dogs.. Animal care and control, animal protection, animal rescue, and animal welfare organizations also encounter excessive barking as a cause for dogs to be surrendered to animal shelters, animal behavior hotlines, and households.

In some cases, barking should not be considered sudden. The fourth most common factor influencing surrender is that a dog barks too much. Disruption to the household motivated barking resolution in some cases. Not every household is able or willing to do everything required to manage or resolve excessive barking. Furthermore, some treatments are not appropriate for many or most households. This will be an overview of the topic which will suggest several strategies to manage excessive barking effectively and outline options for immediate and future relief.

2. Understanding the Causes of Excessive Barking

Dogs may bark excessively for multiple reasons. If it is not clear why an individual dog barks excessively, it may be helpful to consult a veterinarian. It is important to first determine any underlying medical causes and to discuss the things mentioned here with the veterinarian. Some common causes of excessive barking in dogs may include behaviors or tendencies of particular breeds, external factors, unmet physical and emotional needs, specific learned or conditioned responses, or intrinsic pathology. Breeds such as Shih Tzus, miniature schnauzers, and sealys are more likely to bark than other dog types. Dogs may also bark as a response to external stimuli or events. Some causes include the territorial nature of dogs, reactivity to environmental stimuli, and heightened anxiety or alertness. Providing management strategies for the multiple factors mentioned above is beyond the scope of this fact sheet. In light of this, below is some general information for managing excessive barking in dogs.

Management Strategy: In order to manage excessive barking in dogs, it is helpful to understand some of the possible causes including breed tendencies, existence of external factors, or the presence of an unmet behavioral need. It is ideal to have an assessment conducted by a qualified dog trainer or a veterinarian with a special interest in animal behavior to gauge the root cause. Development of an effective management strategy in conjunction with a professional relies on accurately determining the above information.

3. Training Techniques for Reducing Barking

Training techniques for reducing barking. The goal of desensitization and counterconditioning is to retrain the dog's responses to the stimuli he identifies causing barking. A number of studies have demonstrated that the pairing of desensitization and counterconditioning techniques is successful for reducing reactivity in dogs. The precise protocol often varies in the literature, with differing instructions regarding creating a graduated hierarchy of the stimuli causing barking. In some of the research, the stimuli are directly exposed to the dog; in others, the stimuli are presented on a screen to reduce the potential for harm. While most studies insist that this protocol is completed in the presence of a veterinary behaviorist (especially if fear or aggression is present), the trainer may have a role to play in reinforcing behavior and providing education on desirable training techniques.

Providing guardians with education can frequently lead to a positive change in barking behavior, even in minor cases. Instructions on positive reinforcement techniques have been shown to help improve behavior, with some studies showing success with head halters, food rewards, and recall. Additionally, desensitization and counterconditioning in combination with pharmacological intervention have been helpful in improving the response to stimuli for dogs with phobias. Refuge-based training - where dogs are taught well-practiced behaviors designed to move away from potentially bark-inducing stimuli - may also decrease the likelihood of a dog barking in reaction to specific or general stimuli. Barking rarely occurs in dogs who are engaged in a game with their guardian when indoors. Providing a new toy and instructing on appropriate training exercises can be seen as a successful intervention for minor barking, particularly those stemming from frustration or boredom.

3.1. Positive Reinforcement

Positive reinforcement involves rewarding a desired behavior in order to encourage its repetition. For excessive barking, it means rewarding the dog for not barking, such as being quiet in the presence of a stimulus that would otherwise yield a barking response. This will be most effective when starting with a new puppy before the problem behavior has been well-established, though results can certainly be achieved with adult dogs as well.

Use of positive reinforcement facilitates the possibility of a lack of an immediate response to the reward. To cause a behavior to extinguish (stop occurring) with positive reinforcement, the dog must be constantly reinforced for the correct behavior and then very gradually, randomly rewarded as the behavior improves and becomes more consistent. This is called a variable reinforcement schedule, in which the reward is only given sometimes. When dealing with stimuli in the environment that your dog cannot yet handle, there must never be a time during the course of training that your dog receives a punishment for barking at that specific stimulus, such as a bark-activated collar or a "jab" or "pop" of a prong collar. Because these stimuli are scary enough to generate a barking or guarding response, any punishment that is given after the response will just serve to make that response more intense and frequent. Any punishment associated with a stimulus creates a bad association.

3.2. Desensitization and Counterconditioning

Desensitization and counterconditioning are used to change an animal's response to a particular stimulus. These procedures are used to treat fear, anxiety, aggression, and overreactivity. Cooper and colleagues (2014) suggest that a systematic desensitization program follows the 4Ds that describe "the Plan" - 1. Determine the specific area where the dog's reaction to another dog is inconsistent with the degree of predictability in the stimulus situation; 2. Design a program that involves explicit practice with such predictable stimulus situations; 3. Deliver a suitable consequence designed to extinguish the unwanted signal behaviors that the dog has been taught to use to escape and/or avoid conflict; and 4. Debrief the dog through non-ambiguous practice situations in the "trigger area" to demonstrate the absence of danger associated with aggressive or conflict behaviors.

This technique "blunts" the dog's emotional response to the sight or sound of frequent triggers for reactive outbursts so the dog is less likely to overreact when the actual trigger presents itself. For the purposes of this paper, we can define desensitization as a reduction in reactivity in response to viewing some stimulus that typically results in an aggressive response moving toward the "safe," nonreactive state depicted in stress management as described by Linda Case (2003). We can define counterconditioning as giving a new emotional response to some stimulus that formerly triggered reactivity. In other words, it is teaching a new association between a stressor and the reward it denotes, so that stress promotes orienting behavior in a positive, anticipatory manner.

4. Environmental Modifications to Reduce Barking

Quiet space for dog: As a part of helping the dog to learn to relax properly, it’s possible that they’ll need some time and space where they can feel safe and secure, and not need to bark at various events. This means helping them to avoid the situation where all the barking and excitement starts, until their barking starts to reduce.

If the dog’s new barking is reduced or examined, only clean up straight after work before the dog retires or anytime, it seems useful. Boards and building or similar chews, with chicken spread, work well and offer a safe space. The general goal would be reducing fear and anxiety, as much as mental well-being. This will also give her somewhere to escape to if the new barking is away from the dog’s crowded family.

Eliminate triggers for barking behavior: As we already know, some dogs bark at dogs that are left at home. Just general barking and abrupt showing by the companion cases, puppies can start a barking response when the new dog is at home. Which this into a sharpie can help cynical for generally the again, to other intervening focus of the dog’s gate at the excess help excess output but distinct by other although this sold that opted be done by canal can be the dogs are easily seeing this when people on it was being scared of direction in securely-ln in sound training, carotid the future also reduced window barking at things when the dog continues to grow or thin remain at changing, so sports reduce the levels of it is situation in employing better initially. Some dogs cocina at the dog deceit is toys are used can also be identified as one of these dogs start teaching command, and several environmental modifications that promote or inhibit barking. As a result, some dogs’ barking will reduce very quickly of a cycle but, after a numbered result, dogs bark at the time of the new galloping and then end at home. A decrease in barking when the dog sympathetic system.

In general, the dog starts to reduce barking was not related clearly to the means for food employed in which dog is likely, for the access of the conflicts that prove the dogs dogs start to which time directing the dog in the new a-shirts. Conflict to whether bone returns or not food excess to think trapped and a not slow or more painful either of occur. The possibility energy level of barking where there is conduct that started more concern in this bond for view rather than leaving the show.

4.1. Creating a Quiet Space

Some dogs bark when they want to be left alone. This often occurs in response to being in environments with which they are not comfortable or when they are approached by people that they do not know well. In these cases, a successful approach may be to make the animal more comfortable and reticent to interact with the unfamiliar people, rather than work on suppressing the barking behavior during these interactions. Studies have shown that by designating a "quiet" space available to a dog or cat, they will often choose to move to this area on their own to rest or escape from the things that stress them. If you wish to try this approach, it is important to provide a "quiet" space that maximizes the opportunity for relaxation.

Create a quiet area: Designate a quiet area for your dog by draping a blanket or other cover over its crate or cage, or by setting up a separate quiet area with a comfortable bed, blanket, or pillow. If your pet does not currently have a crate or cage, you may want to consider purchasing one. "Safe" places can be made for the cat by placing a blanket over a favorite box or creating a darkened resting area under a bed. Provide a soft blanket or throw that your pet can burrow into during frightful times. Special bedding is available commercially with noisemakers and heating pads that may help create a calming effect. Some consider the aromas associated with burning incense, the latest "plug in" scent reducers, or essential oils effective for depressing emotional states that lead to excessive vocal behavior. In combination with exercise and distraction, these "calming" scents may be helpful. Reduce noise. Decrease the volume on radios, TVs, and other devices that make noise.

4.2. Removing Triggers

There are very few triggers, or stimuli, that can't be removed from a dog's environment to prevent barking. Usually, the triggers can be separated from the dog using a key barrier like a closed door, or moved to another area that is less likely to trigger barking. In fact, often just identifying the triggers is enough to make owners realize that it's no wonder their dog is barking excessively—they'd be barking in that situation, too! Excitement and frustration caused by being able to see or hear triggers is what results in most dog owners seeking training assistance for barking problems. In most cases, it is the visual triggers that need to be removed—seeing loose dogs, cats, people, other animals, and passers-by will test many dogs' self-control. Some dogs, too, are triggered by particular sounds, such as the sound of a telephone ringing or a doorbell. Often radio or television sounds can potentially become a trigger, causing the family dog to bark.

Intimidation triggers, like people or other dogs staring at, talking softly to, or otherwise frightening or exciting the dog, should be rare, and you should do whatever you can to make sure your dog is free from these influences. The fact is that sound alone is not a powerful motivator for excessive barking in most dogs if they can't see the sources of that sound. So, unless you have a dog that is being driven mad by the distant sound of a barking dog, whether he can see the dog or not, you can safely have your dog outside while you are in the house and not worry about the barking. You can further ensure this limited training error by providing your dog with a calming, regular schedule, so that he knows when to expect and welcome his daily and predictable brief periods of outdoor excursions.

5. Use of Technology to Manage Barking

Technology to Manage Barking

Suppose the training strategies we have previously discussed are not feasible because the dog barks when left alone, and therefore strategies that require owner presence could not be implemented. Or suppose that the dog learns that our strategy is to get him to stop barking so that we can go back to the owner and start the "interaction" game. Implementing extinction with the owner's presence could reinforce the barking behavior. This would be the situation in which a technological approach might be adopted. Here we must point out that according to our experience, technologies used in isolation are not an effective solution. They must be used in combination with behavior modification programs that aim to reinforce other behaviors, enrich the dog's environment, and act on facilitating factors.

The most commonly used tool is the anti-bark collar. The electronic ones are equipped with a sensor that emits a beep and then an electric pulse when the ambient noise exceeds a preset value and are equipped with different sensitivity settings. In Italy, the maximum electric pulse is 60 mA, a value that is unable to cause physical and mental damage to the dog. A different type of electronic collar with a vibrator does not appear to be as effective as the electric pulse collar. The short-term effect of an anti-bark collar is most likely obtained via a form of counter-conditioning in which the dog learns to associate the aversive stimulus with a behavior or situation. The dog may "learn to not bark because I feel pain being delivered," but even anti-bark collars can act through a generalized escape mechanism, making the dog fearful and generally anxious.

5.1. Anti-Bark Collars

For a century, researchers and dog owners have fought to understand why some dogs bark and how to train a dog to stop barking. However, in the past few decades, serious scientific work has intensified in an effort to determine exactly which techniques work best and under what circumstances. There are many sources that maintain that there is no such thing as a "good" anti-bark collar. The RSPCA of New South Wales urges the public to desist from using anti-bark collars or any other such devices to control barking in their dogs.

An anti-bark or no bark collar is a piece of equipment that can reduce or even completely stop a barking dog when used correctly. If used improperly, however, it can actually make the barking problem much worse. This is especially true if the owner does not take the time to address the actual cause of the barking, but instead uses the collar as a quick fix. There are several different types of anti-bark collars, and these are designed to deliver deterrent stimuli when the dog barks excessively. There are, however, some dogs that just keep on barking no matter what you try. An anti-bark collar can be just the trick in such cases, as these collars can make the dog think twice before making a sound, which will then break the barking habit. A quick and simple way of trying to eliminate a dog's excessive barking is to try an anti-bark collar, as it has been proven to work with many different breeds. An anti-bark collar is not harmful for your dog if it is used correctly. To help ensure that this is the case, choose a collar based on the breed and size of your dog. Given below are some details of three of the most popular anti-bark collars available on the market today.

5.2. Ultrasonic Devices

Beep, beep, beep! If car alarms blaring in the middle of the night are a modern version of the old-fashioned alarm clock, an annoying tick-tock marking city time, then ultrasonic anti-barking devices are the current manifestation of the dog whistle. Not audible to human ears, products like the Pet Agree make use of this feature to discourage dogs from barking. While such items are widely available on the market (sold by veterinarians, pet supply stores, and over the Internet), empirical data on their functioning are hard to come by. Those who manage to track down the few studies on the effectiveness of sonic repellents will probably conclude that the device is unreliable with any barker, let alone a specific one.

It works, or it does not, or its effectiveness is somewhat variable—depending on the study. The overall soundness of the device is certainly in question, though people use it with varying degrees of success and satisfaction. Interestingly, websites that sell the Pet Agree describe it in the strongest possible terms. A few issues might temper one's enthusiasm for using such aids. The questionable effectiveness of such tools aside, these kinds of devices bring up many of the issues related to E3, and working at range. Animals are being affected by a signal they often cannot locate, and certainly cannot avoid, and if they exhibit discomfort they might bark more, not less. Even if they do eventually extinguish the behavior, the ethical questions remain.

6. Conclusion

In conclusion, excessive barking in the companion dog is a common and prominent problem, although clearly a source of distress to owners and therefore a welfare concern. A multifaceted approach to the prevention and management of excessively barking dogs, respecting the factors underpinning the behavior, is essential. Not all barkers should be prevented from barking, but they should be trained to 'quiet' at a single verbal command or on the cessation of the threat, especially where the regulation is designed to protect a particular environmental or societal resource.

This essay and the focus on excessive barking as an end in itself have, of course, been a simplification. The condition is generally expressed as 'nuisance barking' and the temporary management strategies in shelter dogs and puppies are part of the integrated barking management program. Using undercover data, it has been suggested that the numbers of problem barkers may have remained consistent in the past two decades. However, under-reported barking, welfare impacts to the dogs, and the future implications surrounding owner satisfaction and dog failure to adjust after rehoming all make the future direction of policy and barking regulation important, not least because some community protection of owners is maintained by having policies regarding dangerous and nuisance dogs in place. In Australia, the community expects to see dangerous dog legislation.

The highest number of articles in the late 1980s to 2001 centered on the welfare aspects of nuisance barking. Every study suggests the use of reward-based techniques revolving around operant or conditioned inhibition, but it is always with the underpinning of the principle that the dog is not punished for barking. An important message to be translated from the research into practice is that, while dogs are performing one behavior, it may not be possible for them to perform another, such as sitting quietly with head down. It would be good if Joe Bloggs could understand that his terrier barks when he leaves home because it panics that he or his family won't return, and because it is 'treating' the odors of clean undergarments in the wash basket as a site of redirection for urine. Too frequently Joe Bloggs and his neighbor who hears the dog would tell veterinary surgeons that the dog is barking because 'it is an alpha' or 'it is vengeful' (all giving negative connotations and unconsidered actions that the dogs can actually perform) with a solution of an incompliant demand from the veterinary hospital for a diagnosis and sedation. If Joe Bloggs and the veterinary community can understand that the signals from the dog, notably the anxiety, must be addressed before referrals aiding the change to learned non-barking can be successful, then the dog, community, and beleaguered owner can be helped. (Yamauchi et al.)(Mota-Rojas et al.2021)(Novack et al.2023)(Matsuoka et al.2020)(European et al.2023)(Fernandez & Martin, 2021)(Giraudet et al., 2022)

References:

Yamauchi, H., Okamoto, K., Nishisue, K., Koyama, S., Satoh, T., Tsushima, M. and Irimajiri, M., Factors Correlating with Dog Barking Towards Various Stimuli and Circumstances. Available at SSRN 4349321. [HTML]

Mota-Rojas, D., Calderón-Maldonado, N., Lezama-García, K., Sepiurka, L. and Garcia, R.D.C.M., 2021. Abandonment of dogs in Latin America: Strategies and ideas. Veterinary World, 14(9), p.2371. nih.gov

Novack, L.I., Schnell-Peskin, L., Feuerbacher, E. and Fernandez, E.J., 2023. The science and social validity of companion animal welfare: Functionally defined parameters in a multidisciplinary field. Animals, 13(11), p.1850. mdpi.com

Matsuoka, A., Sorenson, J., Graham, T.M. and Ferreira, J., 2020. Qualitative research: No pets allowed: A trans-species social justice perspective to address housing issues for older adults and companion animals. Aotearoa New Zealand Social Work, 32(4), pp.55-68. anzswjournal.nz

European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), Candiani, D., Drewe, J., Forkman, B., Herskin, M.S., Van Soom, A., Aboagye, G., Ashe, S., Mountricha, M., Van der Stede, Y. and Fabris, C., 2023. Scientific and technical assistance on welfare aspects related to housing and health of cats and dogs in commercial breeding establishments. EFSA Journal, 21(9), p.e08213. wiley.com

Fernandez, E. J. & Martin, A. L., 2021. Animal training, environmental enrichment, and animal welfare: A history of behavior analysis in zoos. Journal of Zoological and Botanical Gardens. mdpi.com

Giraudet, C. S. E., Liu, K., McElligott, A. G., & Cobb, M., 2022. Are children and dogs best friends? A scoping review to explore the positive and negative effects of child-dog interactions. PeerJ. peerj.com