Health Implications of Cats Consuming Dog Food and Strategies for Prevention

1. Introduction

The focus of the essay is on the implications of cats consuming dog food. Cats and dogs are predatory animals and thus share similar kinds of foods, so fur parents must know whether it is unsafe for cats to eat dog food or not. Cats and dogs have some common kinds of food, but there are some differences in the nutrition they require. Cats are obligate carnivores, while dogs are omnivores (Ilias et al., 2022). This implies that cats must eat animal-based protein, and cats require nutrients that dog food does not provide. Cats need taurine, arachidonic acid, and vitamin A, which dogs can produce on their own since their food contains beta-carotene (A. S. Dodd et al., 2021). As a result, feeding cats dog food might result in a taurine deficit and impair cardiac, visual, and reproductive function. Ultimately, cats left stranded on dog food diets for long periods would develop incurable blindness, heart disease, and infertility. In small amounts, dog food is not harmful. Cats will not become ill immediately if they consume dog food, but as a fur parent, it is essential to be aware of health problems that may develop gradually.

A few strategies fur parents can use to ensure that cats do not eat dog food include: removing dog food from common areas; placing dog food in a safe location; training dogs not to eat food unless given the command; using specially designed cat feeding dishes that prevent other pets from eating; feeding dogs directly from their bowls instead of free-feeding; investing in a cat feeder with a collar that only allows cats to eat; thinking of feeding intervals; feeding soft dog food or a different flavor; and being aware of signs that cats have been eating dog food, such as changes in appetite, weight loss or gain, vomiting, diarrhea, or unformed stools.

2. Nutritional Differences Between Dog and Cat Food

Considerable nutritional variances exist among pet foods marketed for cats and dogs. The pet food market is large, diverse, and thriving, with the cat food play segment worth an estimated 5.277 billion USD as of 2021. Cats and dogs have distinct dietary requirements. Extrapolating canine feeding recommendations to obligate carnivores such as cats is inappropriate since the two species have remarkably different evolutionary development and positionality within the kingdom Animalia. Nevertheless, dietary aetiology still forms the basis for differential diagnosis of most common diseases in dogs and cats, notwithstanding disparities in basic nutritional requirements (A. S. Dodd et al., 2021). Dominantly carnivorous, obligate carnivorous cats have greater dietary requirements for arginine, niacin, vitamin A, vitamin D3, and arachidonic acid (AA) than dogs.

While both are orders of mammals of the subclass Eutheria and both belong to the family of domesticated carnivores of the genus Cannus, dogs are schematically classified as facultative carnivores. Genetic selection over the last two centuries has dramatically narrowed dietary diversity among pet dogs, with nutritionally complete and appropriately balanced diets accounted for roughly 90% of total canine food consumption in 2016. On the contrary, cats are strictly carnivorous and have been kept as companion animals for a shorter period.

3. Health Risks for Cats Consuming Dog Food

Cats consuming dog food poses many risks to feline health. In the short run, there are possible digestive issues, such as vomiting, diarrhea, and lack of energy. In the long run, however, there is a possibility of developing nutritional deficiencies and obesity with severe health consequences. While dog food may be “okay” for cats to consume in small amounts, it should never be used as a substitute for a proper diet.

Cats, as obligate carnivores, thrive on a meat-based diet, requiring higher protein and fat levels as well as certain nutritional requirements, such as taurine, arachidonic acid, and vitamin A. While dog food may contain protein, fat, and other nutrients at levels acceptable for sustaining life in a cat, it is not at levels suitable for optimum health. Furthermore, dog food typically lacks the nutrients above that cats cannot synthesize or cannot synthesize at sufficient rates (Knight & Leitsberger, 2016). Even if fed dog food with adequate protein, fat, minerals, and all known vitamins, cats would likely develop hearing loss from taurine deficiency within a few months and retinal degeneration within 1 – 2 years. The lack of arachidonic acid in the diet could cause dry skin and poor coat quality, abnormal renal function, reproduction failure, and improper spinal cord development in kittens (Knight et al., 2023).

3.1. 1.1 Digestive Issues

Cats and canine diets differ significantly by nature. Dogs are omnivores, while cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they thrive on meat-based diets. Dogs can consume a range of ingredients without adverse effects, while cats are much more sensitive to variations in diet. Such differences reflect the evolution of both species. Dogs are scavenging carnivores that adapted to eat a wider variety of foods, while cats prey mostly on small animals high in protein content. Consequently, cats have a greater likelihood of developing digestive disorders when fed dog diets. Regardless of variation types and severities, digestive issues may lead to serious health problems and should be immediately addressed. Herein, the types of digestive issues due to cats consuming dog food are explored. Types of digestive issues caused by dogs in cats are addressed herein.

Many pet owners feed their pets the same food out of convenience or financial considerations. However, such a simple solution can lead to severe health issues for the pet cat. Digestive disorders in cats manifest as acute, chronic, or intermittent vomiting; diarrhea; and route deviation of defecation (e.g., from litter box to floor). Vomiting and diarrhea are two of the most identifiable signs of digestive issues. Two types of vomiting are possible. One type is non-productive vomiting, which is due to hairball formation, and the other type is productive vomiting, typically accompanied by other clinical symptoms.

Productive vomiting is of various forms: 1) acute vomiting (an identifiable cause and less than 24 hours); 2) recurrent vomiting (regular vomiting episodes); and 3) progressive or severe vomiting (weight loss and dehydration; vomiting persists for more than 12 hours accompanied by other clinical signs). Such types of vomiting are often induced by dietary transitions (introduction of new food). Food transition should be gradual (e.g., mix 25% new food with 75% old food), allowing the cat’s digestive system to adjust. Gradual transitioning also refers to the food type fed with the cat, i.e., it is recommended to stick to just wet cat food or dry cat food.

Diarrhea is defined as more than three bowel movements per day with loose, watery stool. This can also be regarded as a change in the stool consistency of one’s cat. Types of diarrhea are classified as 1) acute diarrhea (an identifiable cause with no more than 14 days); 2) chronic diarrhea (more than 14 days and no identifiable cause); and 3) intermittent diarrhea. Similar to vomiting, acute diarrhea is often observed after dietary transitions.

3.2. 1.2 Nutritional Deficiencies

Focusing on nutritional deficiencies, there are often many key nutrients missing in dog food that are important for feline health. It is well-known that a feline-diet needs to be well-balanced in macronutrients, vitamins and minerals, and that feeding them with only one type of food over a long period of time could be dangerous (A. S. Dodd et al., 2021). Some health issues caused by a lack of certain nutrients due to feeding cats with dog food and the natural behaviors of these feline friends—because of their high opportunism—should be considered here. Dog foods are composed of high concentrations of carbohydrates with protein and fat earned from meat and meat by-products. Most of the amino acids such as methionine, taurine, and arginine found in dog food are provided in insufficient concentrations when compared with many kinds of cat food. When fed with dog food, cats with taurine deficiencies may experience retinopathy and declining visual capacity, apart from the well-publicized hypertropic cardiomyopathy. Cats can also develop a form of sudden death due to neurotic convulsion without any prior symptoms. Another common deficiency is arachidonic acid, which may cause flaky skin, poor fur condition, and numerous other apathetic signs. Methionine deficits lead to excessive phosphate body retention, which in turn results in urinary stones or promotion of FLUTD (Feline Lower Urinary Tract Disease). To avoid feeding cats with imbalanced diets like dog food, simple strategies inspired by cats’ instinctive behaviors should be programmed.

3.3. 1.3 Obesity and Weight Management

Weight-related problems are the most common health issues that pet owners address with their veterinarian for their cats (J. German, 2016). There is a significant association between lifetime dietary habits and yearly nutrient intake in cats and obesity (Wall et al., 2019). Managing a cat’s weight is essential to its health, wellbeing, and quality of life. Addressing overweight and obesity is critical to preventing all complications associated with excess weight.

4. Strategies to Prevent Cats from Eating Dog Food

In the face of the unforeseen hazard posed by cats consuming dog food, being proactive is essential in safeguarding feline health. Proactive strategies can help to prevent cats from eating dog food. They generally cover three areas: feeding separation, choosing the right cat food, and behavioral training techniques.

Feeding separation is perhaps the most effective way to protect cats from both dog food and its dangers. Cats should have a designated feeding area where dog food cannot be accessed. The feline feeding station should ideally be a room with a door or an area blocked off from canines. If the kitty station must share space with dogs, consider getting an elevated feeding dish or food containers that can only be accessed by a cat’s head but not dog snouts (Wall et al., 2019). Both of these options also have the added benefit of giving the cat a sense of security, which may help dish shyness issues in multi-animal households.

There are also cat food options that may make dog food less appetizing to felines. Dry cat foods that are higher in fat content (≥15%) tend to have a greater luring effect on feral cats than dog food (≥4%). These types of cat food may help prevent cats from feeling the need to steal dog food to get a higher fix of fatty nutrients. Despite challenges, making the right changes to both the feeding area and what cat food is provided is the most effective means of keeping cats safe from eating dog food.

4.1. 2.1 Feeding Separation

One potential solution to mitigate the risks associated with cats consuming dog food is ensuring proper feeding separation. This strategy involves creating distinct feeding areas for cats and dogs to prevent felines from accessing the canine diet. Supervision during feeding times is crucial, particularly when the pets are first introduced or when finding the appropriate cat food takes time. Feeding separation can be implemented by setting designated spaces for each pet, preferably out of sight of one another, and installing gates in doorways that block the pet-sized access (Raspa et al., 2023). Positive reinforcement should be employed, rewarding pets for using their respective diet and space, with further reinforcement during the first few supervised feedings.

In addition, automatic feeding devices that only open for a specific pet with a microchip or collar tag can be exceedingly helpful. Cats tend to eat dog food more frequently while other pets are present (Luisana et al., 2022). Designing feeding times that align with the owner's schedule—for instance, after work—can prevent both pets from eating concurrently. Elevated food bowls hinder smaller pets, especially if the larger pet is a dog. Alternatively, feeding the dog in a different room while keeping the cat's door closed can ensure feeding separation. When cats and dogs are free-fed, pet owners must regularly monitor their diets to detect if a pet is consuming food more quickly.

4.2. 2.2 Choosing the Right Cat Food

The selection of the appropriate cat food is vital in preventing cats from eating dog food. It is essential to choose cat food that meets the nutritional needs of felines, including proteins, taurine, arachidonic acid, vitamins, taurine, calcium, zinc, and dietary fiber. To ensure that cats are provided with the right diet, it is important to pay attention to the ingredients, avoid feeding your cats homemade diets, conduct research before making a switch, look for premium quality products, and avoid sudden changes to their food (A. Alegría-Morán et al., 2019). With the right diet, feline nutrient requirements are satisfied, making it less likely for cats to look for alternative sources of nutrition, including dog food.

Cats are strict carnivores with particular macronutritional needs that are essential to their physiology. Cat food is advertised to contain the right ingredients for healthy and palatable moist or dry diets. Ingredients often seen on labels include chicken, fish, beef, turkey, or food with a comprehensive name, like “meat by-products” (Ilias et al., 2022). On the other hand, dog food is usually based on other ingredients, like cereal flour, and is mainly vegetable-based. Dog dry food is also biscuit-like and mostly contains grain and chicken meal. Since they are fed different diets than those ideally suited to their physiology, pets have different feeding behaviors and physical traits.

4.3. 2.3 Behavioral Training Techniques

Training techniques to discourage behaviors are often easiest through the use of a pet that eats dog food as the training target. The most common techniques include positive reinforcement, shaping, and modeling. Positive reinforcement relies on providing a stimulus that is more favorable than the subject’s state following the behavior. Continued response usually leads to the event repetition due to an increase in focus and reward (Wall et al., 2019). Positive reinforcement that has been shown to encourage and maintain a behavior is the intermittent schedules of rewards. This schedules divides responses throughout a time interval with varied timing of reward outcomes. Training through the use of an intermittent schedule can take longer to establish the target behavior but leads to higher persistence. Shaping consists of successive approximations to a goal behavior by rewarding the closest to the target behavior. This usually leads to rapid adaptation to the new behavior or sequence of behaviors. Modeling consists of showing the subject the desired outcome of the trained behavior. The model can be an expert individual of the same species or similar and has been shown to lead to quick and accurate adaptation (A. Alegría-Morán et al., 2019).

5. Conclusion and Recommendations

The health implications of cats consuming dog food are a significant concern for pet owners and caregivers. Dog food is not formulated for the specific dietary needs of cats and can lead to a variety of health issues. One of the main health risks is the deficiency of taurine, an essential amino acid for cats. Dogs can synthesize taurine, while cats cannot, and a lack of this nutrient can result in blindness, heart disease, and reproductive problems. In addition, dog food is typically higher in carbohydrates than cat food, which can lead to obesity and diabetes in felines. Other potential issues include vitamin A deficiency and urinary tract problems. These health implications underscore the importance of keeping cat and dog food separate and ensuring that cats have access only to food that meets their dietary needs.

To prevent cats from consuming dog food, it is essential for pet owners and caregivers to be proactive. One of the most effective strategies is to feed cats and dogs in separate areas and at different times to minimize the chance of food theft. Additionally, it may be helpful to provide higher cat feeding stations in the home, as dogs cannot reach these areas. If a cat is continuously stealing dog food, it may be necessary to consult a veterinarian to ensure that the cat's dietary needs are being met. Overall, understanding the health implications of cats consuming dog food and implementing prevention strategies can help ensure that feline companions remain healthy and thriving (MacMartin et al., 2023) , (Wall et al., 2019).

References:

Ilias, N., Harris Hakim Zaki, A., Hazmi Awang Junaidi, A., Seng Fong, L., Saufi, I., & Ajat, M., 2022. Palatability assessment of prescribed diets on domestic shorthair cats. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

A. S. Dodd, S., Dewey, C., Khosa, D., & Verbrugghe, A., 2021. A cross-sectional study of owner-reported health in Canadian and American cats fed meat- and plant-based diets. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

A. S. Dodd, S., K. Shoveller, A., J. Fascetti, A., Z. Yu, Z., W. L. Ma, D., & Verbrugghe, A., 2021. A Comparison of Key Essential Nutrients in Commercial Plant-Based Pet Foods Sold in Canada to American and European Canine and Feline Dietary Recommendations. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Knight, A. & Leitsberger, M., 2016. Vegetarian versus Meat-Based Diets for Companion Animals. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Knight, A., Bauer, A., & Brown, H., 2023. Vegan versus meat-based cat food: Guardian-reported health outcomes in 1,369 cats, after controlling for feline demographic factors. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

J. German, A., 2016. Weight management in obese pets: the tailoring concept and how it can improve results. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Wall, M., John Cave, N., & Vallee, E., 2019. Owner and Cat-Related Risk Factors for Feline Overweight or Obesity. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Raspa, F., Schiavone, A., Pattono, D., Galaverna, D., Cavallini, D., Vinassa, M., Bergero, D., Dalmasso, A., Teresa Bottero, M., & Valle, E., 2023. Pet feeding habits and the microbiological contamination of dog food bowls: effect of feed type, cleaning method and bowl material. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Luisana, E., Saker, K., Jaykus, L. A., & Getty, C., 2022. Survey evaluation of dog owners’ feeding practices and dog bowls’ hygiene assessment in domestic settings. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

A. Alegría-Morán, R., A. Guzmán-Pino, S., I. Egaña, J., Sotomayor, V., & Figueroa, J., 2019. Food Preferences in Cats: Effect of Dietary Composition and Intrinsic Variables on Diet Selection. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

MacMartin, C., Wheat, H., & B. Coe, J., 2023. Conversation Analysis of Clients’ Active Resistance to Veterinarians’ Proposals for Long-Term Dietary Change in Companion Animal Practice in Ontario, Canada. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov